{"schema_version":"living-evidence-note/1","note_id":"note-ingredient-order","slug":"tallow-balm-ingredient-order","question":"What does ingredient order on a tallow balm label tell you?","intended_decision":"Understand what the first-listed ingredient can and cannot establish.","answer":"Of 96 current records with a supported ingredient list, 61 list a reviewed tallow term first and 35 list it later.","scope":"The answer describes label order in the current records. It does not calculate ingredient percentages.","method":"Read the first supported ingredient-list entry, resolve reviewed tallow aliases, and keep missing lists unknown.","metrics":[{"label":"Tallow term first","value":"61"},{"label":"Tallow term later","value":"35"},{"label":"Ingredient list unknown","value":"4"}],"limits":["FDA guidance says cosmetic ingredients are generally listed in descending order of predominance.","Ingredients at one percent or less can be listed in any order after ingredients above one percent. Color additives have another ordering exception.","Label order does not reveal exact percentages and does not establish quality or performance."],"release":{"id":"rel-v1.0.0","version":"v1.0.0","status":"published","freshness":{"oldestCheckedAt":"2026-08-27T17:10:00Z","newestCheckedAt":"2026-08-31T17:30:00Z"}},"result_hash":"e606b510a1c91ee9d1a0d5d299d68073557cd6c8671d93bdfdef40ef51b0883a","results":[{"product_id":"prod-amallow-baby-bum-balm","variant_id":"var-amallow-baby-bum-balm-4oz","slug":"amallow-baby-bum-balm-4oz","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Baby Bum Balm","exact_variant":"4 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-baby-bum-balm-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-baby-bum-balm-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-clean-cloud","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-clean-cloud-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-clean-cloud-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Clean Cloud","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-clean-cloud-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-clean-cloud-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-orange-creamsicle","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-orange-creamsicle-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-orange-creamsicle-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Orange Creamsicle","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-orange-creamsicle-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-orange-creamsicle-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-unscented","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Unscented","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-unscented-jojoba","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Unscented + Jojoba Oil","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-vanilla-latte","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-vanilla-latte-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-vanilla-latte-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Vanilla Latte","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-vanilla-latte-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-vanilla-latte-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-vanilla-lavender","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-vanilla-lavender-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-vanilla-lavender-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Vanilla Lavender","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-vanilla-lavender-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-vanilla-lavender-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-ancestral-cosmetics-tallow-body-cream","variant_id":"var-ancestral-cosmetics-tallow-body-cream-120ml-1pack","slug":"ancestral-cosmetics-tallow-body-cream-120ml-1pack","brand":"Ancestral Cosmetics","product_name":"Tallow Body Cream","exact_variant":"1 pack, 120 ml / 4 oz","finding":"First: Irish Grass-fed, Pasture-Raised Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ancestral-cosmetics-tallow-body-cream-120ml-1pack","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ancestral-cosmetics-tallow-body-cream-120ml-1pack"},{"product_id":"prd-ancestral-unscented","variant_id":"var-ancestral-unscented-60ml","slug":"ancestral-unscented-tallow-honey-60ml","brand":"Ancestral Cosmetics","product_name":"Unscented Tallow & Honey Balm","exact_variant":"Unscented, 60 ml","finding":"First: Irish Grass-fed, Pasture Raised Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ancestral-unscented-tallow-honey-60ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ancestral-unscented-tallow-honey-60ml"},{"product_id":"prod-austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-austallow-balm","slug":"austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm-50g","brand":"AusTallow","product_name":"Grass-Fed Tallow Balm Moisturizer","exact_variant":"50 g","finding":"First: Grass-fed Australian tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm-50g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm-50g"},{"product_id":"prd-bare-tallow","variant_id":"var-bare-tallow-130g","slug":"bare-tallow-face-body-butter-130g","brand":"BARE BODY BEAUTY Co","product_name":"Bare Tallow Face + Body Butter","exact_variant":"Standard, 130 g","finding":"First: 100% Organic Grass Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/bare-tallow-face-body-butter-130g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/bare-tallow-face-body-butter-130g"},{"product_id":"prod-better-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-better-tallow-unscented","slug":"better-tallow-balm-unscented-1-5oz","brand":"Better Tallow","product_name":"Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Unscented, 1.5 oz","finding":"No complete supported list in this release","evidence_state":"conflicted","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/better-tallow-balm-unscented-1-5oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/better-tallow-balm-unscented-1-5oz"},{"product_id":"prod-birthright-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-birthright-tallow-balm-2oz","slug":"birthright-tallow-balm-2oz","brand":"Birthright","product_name":"Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz / 59 ml","finding":"No complete supported list in this release","evidence_state":"unknown","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/birthright-tallow-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/birthright-tallow-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-herbal-comfort-balm","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-herbal-tallow-balm-default","slug":"buffalo-gal-herbal-tallow-balm-default","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Herbal Comfort Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"No complete supported list in this release","evidence_state":"unknown","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-herbal-tallow-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-herbal-tallow-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default","slug":"buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Tallow + Emu Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% grassfed tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-tallow-cleansing-balm","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-tallow-cleansing-balm-2oz","slug":"buffalo-gal-tallow-cleansing-balm-2oz","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Tallow Cleansing Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% grassfed tallow infused with organic rosebuds, organic lavender buds, organic calendula flowers and organic lemon peel","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-tallow-cleansing-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-tallow-cleansing-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-tallow-face-balm-dry-maturing-skin","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-tallow-face-balm-33oz-no-essential-oils","slug":"buffalo-gal-tallow-face-balm-33oz-no-essential-oils","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Tallow Face Balm","exact_variant":"No essential oils added, 3.3 oz","finding":"First: 100% grassfed water buffalo tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-tallow-face-balm-33oz-no-essential-oils","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-tallow-face-balm-33oz-no-essential-oils"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-tallow-lip-balm","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-tallow-lip-balm-013oz-virgin","slug":"buffalo-gal-tallow-lip-balm-013oz-virgin","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Tallow Lip Balm","exact_variant":"Virgin, 0.13 oz","finding":"First: Grassfed tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-tallow-lip-balm-013oz-virgin","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-tallow-lip-balm-013oz-virgin"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-unscented-body-butter-bar","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-unscented-body-butter-bar-3oz","slug":"buffalo-gal-unscented-body-butter-bar-3oz","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Unscented Body Butter Bar","exact_variant":"3 oz","finding":"First: Grassfed tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-unscented-body-butter-bar-3oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-unscented-body-butter-bar-3oz"},{"product_id":"prod-buttr-tallow-skin-balm","variant_id":"var-buttr-skin-balm","slug":"buttr-tallow-skin-balm-2-7oz","brand":"BUTTR Beauty","product_name":"BUTTR Tallow Skin Balm","exact_variant":"2.7 oz","finding":"First: Grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buttr-tallow-skin-balm-2-7oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buttr-tallow-skin-balm-2-7oz"},{"product_id":"prod-culver-unscented-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-culver-unscented-4oz","slug":"culver-unscented-whipped-tallow-4oz","brand":"Culver Family Farms","product_name":"Unscented Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"4 fl oz","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/culver-unscented-whipped-tallow-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/culver-unscented-whipped-tallow-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-dr-kellyann-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar","slug":"dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar","brand":"Dr. Kellyann","product_name":"Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"1 Jar","finding":"First: Water; tallow at 2","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Bare Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Calendula and Rose Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Jojoba Oil and Manuka Honey Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Jojoba Oil Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-kawakawa-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-kawakawa-tallow-balm-100ml","slug":"ever-tallow-kawakawa-tallow-balm-100ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Kawakawa Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"100 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-kawakawa-tallow-balm-100ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-kawakawa-tallow-balm-100ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Vanilla Bean Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-winter-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-winter-tallow-balm-100ml","slug":"ever-tallow-winter-tallow-balm-100ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Winter Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"100 ml","finding":"First: 100% grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-winter-tallow-balm-100ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-winter-tallow-balm-100ml"},{"product_id":"prd-fatco-cleansing","variant_id":"var-fatco-cleansing-2oz","slug":"fatco-cleansing-balm-2oz","brand":"FATCO","product_name":"Cleansing Balm","exact_variant":"Standard, 2 oz","finding":"First: Coconut Oil; tallow at 2","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/fatco-cleansing-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/fatco-cleansing-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented","variant_id":"var-fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default","slug":"fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default","brand":"Fierce Nature","product_name":"Nourish Balm (Unscented)","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (Tallow); tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default"},{"product_id":"prod-hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm","variant_id":"var-hearth-herb-unscented","slug":"hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm-1-3oz","brand":"Hearth and Homestead","product_name":"Herb-Infused Unscented Whipped Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Small, 1.3 oz","finding":"First: Grass-fed and finished tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm-1-3oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm-1-3oz"},{"product_id":"prod-herd-tallow-beef-tallow-moisturizer","variant_id":"var-herd-unscented-2oz","slug":"herd-tallow-moisturizer-unscented-2oz","brand":"Herd Tallow","product_name":"Beef Tallow Moisturizer","exact_variant":"Unscented, 2 oz","finding":"First: Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/herd-tallow-moisturizer-unscented-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/herd-tallow-moisturizer-unscented-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-hog-and-tallow-tallow-balm-bee","variant_id":"var-hog-tallow-bee","slug":"hog-and-tallow-tallow-balm-bee-100g","brand":"Hog and Tallow","product_name":"Tallow Balm Bee","exact_variant":"100 g","finding":"First: Grass-fed tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/hog-and-tallow-tallow-balm-bee-100g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/hog-and-tallow-tallow-balm-bee-100g"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-bare-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-bare-tallow-balm-default","slug":"kai-bare-tallow-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Bare Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Beef Tallow*","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-bare-tallow-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-bare-tallow-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-golden-glow-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-golden-glow-tallow-balm-default","slug":"kai-golden-glow-tallow-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Golden Glow Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Beef Tallow*","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-golden-glow-tallow-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-golden-glow-tallow-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-infused-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-infused-tallow-balm-default","slug":"kai-infused-tallow-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Infused Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Beef Tallow*","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-infused-tallow-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-infused-tallow-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-original-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-original-tallow-balm-2oz","slug":"kai-original-tallow-balm-2oz","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Original Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: Beef Tallow*","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-original-tallow-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-original-tallow-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-original-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-original-tallow-balm-4oz","slug":"kai-original-tallow-balm-4oz","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Original Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"4 oz","finding":"First: Beef Tallow*","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-original-tallow-balm-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-original-tallow-balm-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-tallow-body-lotion","variant_id":"var-kai-tallow-body-lotion-default","slug":"kai-tallow-body-lotion-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Tallow Body Lotion","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Aqua (Filtered Water); tallow at 2","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-tallow-body-lotion-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-tallow-body-lotion-default"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-tallow-lip-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-tallow-lip-balm-default","slug":"kai-tallow-lip-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Tallow Lip Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Beef Tallow*","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-tallow-lip-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-tallow-lip-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-winter-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-winter-balm-default","slug":"kai-winter-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Winter Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-winter-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-winter-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-lipidology-unscented-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-lipidology-unscented","slug":"lipidology-unscented-tallow-balm-standard","brand":"Lipidology","product_name":"Unscented Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Standard","finding":"No complete supported list in this release","evidence_state":"conflicted","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/lipidology-unscented-tallow-balm-standard","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/lipidology-unscented-tallow-balm-standard"},{"product_id":"prod-nudae-nourishing-balm","variant_id":"var-nudae-nourishing-balm-default","slug":"nudae-nourishing-balm-default","brand":"Nudae","product_name":"Nourishing Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: NZ Grass-Fed Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/nudae-nourishing-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/nudae-nourishing-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-nz-tallow-unscented-balm","variant_id":"var-nz-tallow-unscented","slug":"nz-tallow-unscented-balm-70g","brand":"NZ Tallow Co","product_name":"Unscented Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"70 g / 120 ml","finding":"First: Purified beef tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/nz-tallow-unscented-balm-70g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/nz-tallow-unscented-balm-70g"},{"product_id":"prod-primally-pure-antioxidant-balm","variant_id":"var-primally-pure-antioxidant-balm-1oz","slug":"primally-pure-antioxidant-balm-1oz","brand":"Primally Pure","product_name":"Antioxidant Balm","exact_variant":"1 oz","finding":"First: Organic Tallow from Grass-Fed Cows","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/primally-pure-antioxidant-balm-1oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/primally-pure-antioxidant-balm-1oz"},{"product_id":"prd-pp-baby","variant_id":"var-pp-baby-1oz","slug":"primally-pure-baby-balm-1oz","brand":"Primally Pure","product_name":"Baby Balm","exact_variant":"Unscented, 1 oz","finding":"First: Organic Tallow from Grass-Fed Cows","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/primally-pure-baby-balm-1oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/primally-pure-baby-balm-1oz"},{"product_id":"prod-primally-pure-clarifying-cream","variant_id":"var-primally-pure-clarifying-cream-1oz","slug":"primally-pure-clarifying-cream-1oz","brand":"Primally Pure","product_name":"Clarifying Cream","exact_variant":"1 oz","finding":"First: Organic Tallow from Grass-Fed Cows","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/primally-pure-clarifying-cream-1oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/primally-pure-clarifying-cream-1oz"},{"product_id":"prd-pp-everything","variant_id":"var-pp-everything-1oz","slug":"primally-pure-everything-balm-1oz","brand":"Primally Pure","product_name":"Everything Balm","exact_variant":"Standard, 1 oz","finding":"First: Organic Tallow from Grass-Fed Cows","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/primally-pure-everything-balm-1oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/primally-pure-everything-balm-1oz"},{"product_id":"prod-primally-pure-plumping-cream","variant_id":"var-primally-pure-plumping-cream-1oz","slug":"primally-pure-plumping-cream-1oz","brand":"Primally Pure","product_name":"Plumping Cream","exact_variant":"1 oz","finding":"First: Organic Tallow From Grass-Fed Cows","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/primally-pure-plumping-cream-1oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/primally-pure-plumping-cream-1oz"},{"product_id":"prod-primally-pure-soothing-cream","variant_id":"var-primally-pure-soothing-cream-1oz","slug":"primally-pure-soothing-cream-1oz","brand":"Primally Pure","product_name":"Soothing Cream","exact_variant":"1 oz","finding":"First: Organic Tallow From Grass-Fed Cows","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/primally-pure-soothing-cream-1oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/primally-pure-soothing-cream-1oz"},{"product_id":"prod-raw-tide-grass-fed-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-raw-tide-balm","slug":"raw-tide-grass-fed-tallow-balm-3oz","brand":"Raw Tide","product_name":"Grass-Fed Tallow Face and Body Balm","exact_variant":"3 oz","finding":"First: Grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/raw-tide-grass-fed-tallow-balm-3oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/raw-tide-grass-fed-tallow-balm-3oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz","slug":"rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Lavender Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed & Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz","slug":"rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Vanilla Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed & Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-whipped-tallow-2oz","slug":"rowe-whipped-tallow-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed & Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-whipped-tallow-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-whipped-tallow-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-extra-strength-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-rowe-extra-strength-tallow-balm-2oz","slug":"rowe-extra-strength-tallow-balm-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"Extra Strength Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed & Grass-Finished Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-extra-strength-tallow-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-extra-strength-tallow-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-original-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-rowe-original-tallow-balm-2oz","slug":"rowe-original-tallow-balm-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"Original Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-original-tallow-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-original-tallow-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prd-ruth-whipped","variant_id":"var-ruth-whipped-unscented-4oz","slug":"ruth-whipped-tallow-unscented-4oz","brand":"Ruth Family Farms","product_name":"Whipped Beef Tallow","exact_variant":"Unscented, 4 oz","finding":"First: 100% Rendered Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ruth-whipped-tallow-unscented-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ruth-whipped-tallow-unscented-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-age-reverse","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-age-reverse-default","slug":"sun-moo-age-reverse-default","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Age Reverse","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Grass Fed & Finished Suet Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-age-reverse-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-age-reverse-default"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-gentle-one","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-gentle-one-34oz","slug":"sun-moo-gentle-one-34oz","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Gentle One","exact_variant":"3.4 oz","finding":"First: Grass-fed & Grass-finished Suet Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-gentle-one-34oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-gentle-one-34oz"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-healer","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-healer-default","slug":"sun-moo-healer-default","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Healer","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Grass Fed & Finished Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-healer-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-healer-default"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-lip-01","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-lip-01-default","slug":"sun-moo-lip-01-default","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Lip 01","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Grass-fed & Grass-finished Suet Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-lip-01-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-lip-01-default"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-simple-one","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-simple-one-2oz","slug":"sun-moo-simple-one-2oz","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Simple One","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed & Grass-Finished Suet Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-simple-one-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-simple-one-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-sveda-whipped-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-sveda-whipped-tallow-balm","slug":"sveda-whipped-tallow-balm-standard","brand":"SVEDA","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Standard","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sveda-whipped-tallow-balm-standard","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sveda-whipped-tallow-balm-standard"},{"product_id":"prd-tov-grass-fed","variant_id":"var-tov-grass-fed-3-4oz","slug":"tov-grass-fed-tallow-3-4oz","brand":"T.O.V. Organics","product_name":"TOV Grass Fed Beef Tallow","exact_variant":"Standard, 3.4 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tov-grass-fed-tallow-3-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tov-grass-fed-tallow-3-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tall-owl-baby-balm","variant_id":"var-tall-owl-baby-balm-2oz","slug":"tall-owl-baby-balm-2oz","brand":"Tall Owl","product_name":"Baby Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tall-owl-baby-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tall-owl-baby-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tall-owl-freedom-balm","variant_id":"var-tall-owl-freedom-balm-2oz","slug":"tall-owl-freedom-balm-2oz","brand":"Tall Owl","product_name":"Freedom Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tall-owl-freedom-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tall-owl-freedom-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tall-owl-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz","slug":"tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz","brand":"Tall Owl","product_name":"Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"Unscented / 3.0 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tallo-skin-all-things-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallo-skin-all-things-tallow-balm-50ml","slug":"tallo-skin-all-things-tallow-balm-50ml","brand":"Tallo Skin","product_name":"All Things Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"50 ml / 55 g","finding":"First: Grass-Finished Tallow*; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallo-skin-all-things-tallow-balm-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallo-skin-all-things-tallow-balm-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tallo-skin-hydrating-tallow-lip-balm","variant_id":"var-tallo-skin-hydrating-lip-balm-original-10ml","slug":"tallo-skin-hydrating-lip-balm-original-10ml","brand":"Tallo Skin","product_name":"Hydrating Tallow Lip Balm","exact_variant":"Original / 10 ml","finding":"First: Grass-Finished Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallo-skin-hydrating-lip-balm-original-10ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallo-skin-hydrating-lip-balm-original-10ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tallo-skin-sea-buckthorn-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallo-skin-sea-buckthorn-tallow-balm-50ml","slug":"tallo-skin-sea-buckthorn-tallow-balm-50ml","brand":"Tallo Skin","product_name":"Sea Buckthorn Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"50 ml / 55 g","finding":"First: Grass-Finished Tallow*; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallo-skin-sea-buckthorn-tallow-balm-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallo-skin-sea-buckthorn-tallow-balm-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml","slug":"tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml","brand":"Tallo Skin","product_name":"Skin Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"100 ml","finding":"First: Grass-fed and finished tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-balm-company-tallow-body-butter","variant_id":"var-tallow-balm-company-tallow-body-butter-4oz","slug":"tallow-balm-company-tallow-body-butter-4oz","brand":"Tallow Balm Company","product_name":"Tallow Body Butter","exact_variant":"4 oz","finding":"First: USDA Organic 100% Grass-Fed & Finished Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-balm-company-tallow-body-butter-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-balm-company-tallow-body-butter-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-balm-shop-honey-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-balm-shop-honey-100g","slug":"tallow-balm-shop-honey-tallow-balm-100g","brand":"Tallow Balm Shop","product_name":"Honey Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"100 g","finding":"First: Grass Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-balm-shop-honey-tallow-balm-100g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-balm-shop-honey-tallow-balm-100g"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-balm-shop-original-100g","slug":"tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm-100g","brand":"Tallow Balm Shop","product_name":"Original Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"100 g","finding":"First: Grass Fed Beef Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm-100g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm-100g"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-balm-shop-original-whipped-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-balm-shop-whipped-100g","slug":"tallow-balm-shop-original-whipped-tallow-balm-100g","brand":"Tallow Balm Shop","product_name":"Original Whipped Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"100 g","finding":"First: Aqua; tallow at 2","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-balm-shop-original-whipped-tallow-balm-100g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-balm-shop-original-whipped-tallow-balm-100g"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-balm-shop-tallow-lip-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-balm-shop-lip-5g","slug":"tallow-balm-shop-tallow-lip-balm-5g","brand":"Tallow Balm Shop","product_name":"Tallow Lip Balm","exact_variant":"5 g","finding":"First: Paraffinum liquidum (mineral oil); tallow at 12","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-balm-shop-tallow-lip-balm-5g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-balm-shop-tallow-lip-balm-5g"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-bar-face-body-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-bar-face-body","slug":"tallow-bar-face-body-balm-100g","brand":"Tallow Bar","product_name":"Tallow Face and Body Balm","exact_variant":"100 g","finding":"First: Grass-fed and finished suet beef tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-bar-face-body-balm-100g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-bar-face-body-balm-100g"},{"product_id":"prod-tallowbourn-grass-fed-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallowbourn-grass-fed-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","slug":"tallowbourn-grass-fed-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","brand":"Tallowbourn","product_name":"Grass-Fed Tallow Balm for Face & Body","exact_variant":"Unscented, 2 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallowbourn-grass-fed-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallowbourn-grass-fed-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-talova-face-body-balm","variant_id":"var-talova-face-body-balm-2oz","slug":"talova-face-body-balm-2oz","brand":"TALOVA","product_name":"Face + Body Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: Tallow (Grass-Fed Beef, Pure Rendered)","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/talova-face-body-balm-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/talova-face-body-balm-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tarro-bare-skin-balm","variant_id":"var-tarro-bare-skin-balm-default","slug":"tarro-bare-skin-balm-default","brand":"Tarro","product_name":"Bare Skin Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (tallow); tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tarro-bare-skin-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tarro-bare-skin-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-tarro-calm-balm","variant_id":"var-tarro-calm-balm-30g","slug":"tarro-calm-balm-30g","brand":"Tarro","product_name":"Calm Balm","exact_variant":"30 g","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (tallow); tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tarro-calm-balm-30g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tarro-calm-balm-30g"},{"product_id":"prod-tayyib-tree-tallow-honey-whipped-balm","variant_id":"var-tayyib-tree-tallow-honey-balm-classic-60ml","slug":"tayyib-tree-tallow-honey-balm-classic-60ml","brand":"Tayyib Tree","product_name":"Tallow & Honey Whipped Balm","exact_variant":"Classic Unisex Scent / 60 ml (2 oz)","finding":"First: Halal Grass-fed Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tayyib-tree-tallow-honey-balm-classic-60ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tayyib-tree-tallow-honey-balm-classic-60ml"},{"product_id":"prod-the-cow-balm-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-cow-balm-unscented","slug":"the-cow-balm-unscented-50ml","brand":"The Cow Balm","product_name":"Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Unscented, 50 ml","finding":"First: Grass-fed beef tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/the-cow-balm-unscented-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/the-cow-balm-unscented-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-thyme-original-unscented-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-thyme-original","slug":"tallow-thyme-original-unscented-balm-60ml","brand":"The Tallow and Thyme Company","product_name":"Original Unscented Whipped Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"60 ml","finding":"First: Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-thyme-original-unscented-balm-60ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-thyme-original-unscented-balm-60ml"},{"product_id":"prod-toups-hydrating-tallow-stick","variant_id":"var-toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-default","slug":"toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-standard","brand":"Toups and Co Organics","product_name":"Hydrating Tallow Stick","exact_variant":"Standard","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-standard","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-standard"},{"product_id":"prd-toups-original","variant_id":"var-toups-original-2oz","slug":"toups-tallow-balm-original-2oz","brand":"Toups and Co Organics","product_name":"Tallow Balm Original","exact_variant":"Original, 2 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/toups-tallow-balm-original-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/toups-tallow-balm-original-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-toups-tallow-balm-unscented","variant_id":"var-toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","slug":"toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","brand":"Toups and Co Organics","product_name":"Tallow Balm Unscented","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"First: Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm","variant_id":"var-tricity-pure-200ml","slug":"tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-200ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Pure Tallow Skin Balm","exact_variant":"200 ml","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (Beef Tallow)","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-200ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-200ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-trial","variant_id":"var-tricity-pure-60ml","slug":"tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-60ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Pure Tallow Skin Balm Trial","exact_variant":"60 ml","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (Beef Tallow)","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-60ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-60ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm","variant_id":"var-tricity-honey-200ml","slug":"tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm-200ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Tallow and Honey Skin Balm","exact_variant":"200 ml","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (Beef Tallow)","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm-200ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm-200ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter","variant_id":"var-tricity-whipped-200ml","slug":"tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter-200ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Body Butter","exact_variant":"200 ml","finding":"First: Adeps Bovis (Beef Tallow)","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter-200ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter-200ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tropical-tallow-body-balm","variant_id":"var-tropical-tallow-body-balm-default","slug":"tropical-tallow-body-balm-default","brand":"Tropical Tallow","product_name":"Body Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tropical-tallow-body-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tropical-tallow-body-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-tropical-tallow-citrus-balm","variant_id":"var-tropical-tallow-citrus-balm-default","slug":"tropical-tallow-citrus-balm-default","brand":"Tropical Tallow","product_name":"Citrus Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tropical-tallow-citrus-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tropical-tallow-citrus-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-tropical-tallow-rescue-balm","variant_id":"var-tropical-tallow-rescue-balm-default","slug":"tropical-tallow-rescue-balm-default","brand":"Tropical Tallow","product_name":"Rescue Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"First: 100% Grass-Fed Tallow","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tropical-tallow-rescue-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tropical-tallow-rescue-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-vanman-no-essential-oils-tallow-honey-face-balm-classic","variant_id":"var-vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz","slug":"vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz","brand":"VanMan","product_name":"No Essential Oils Tallow & Honey Face Balm - Classic","exact_variant":"Jumbo 6 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass Fed & Finished Suet Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz"},{"product_id":"prod-vanman-no-essential-oils-tallow-honey-face-balm-classic","variant_id":"var-vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz","slug":"vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz","brand":"VanMan","product_name":"No Essential Oils Tallow & Honey Face Balm - Classic","exact_variant":"Original 2 oz","finding":"First: 100% Grass Fed & Finished Suet Beef Tallow; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-vintage-tradition-mild-manly-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-vintage-tradition-mild-manly-2floz","slug":"vintage-tradition-mild-manly-2floz","brand":"Vintage Tradition","product_name":"Mild Manly Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 fl oz / 59 ml","finding":"First: Tallow from 100% grass-fed cows; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vintage-tradition-mild-manly-2floz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vintage-tradition-mild-manly-2floz"},{"product_id":"prod-vintage-tradition-pretty-girly-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-vintage-tradition-pretty-girly-2floz","slug":"vintage-tradition-pretty-girly-2floz","brand":"Vintage Tradition","product_name":"Pretty Girly Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 fl oz / 59 ml","finding":"First: Tallow from 100% grass-fed cows; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vintage-tradition-pretty-girly-2floz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vintage-tradition-pretty-girly-2floz"},{"product_id":"prod-vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz","slug":"vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz","brand":"Vintage Tradition","product_name":"Totally Unscented Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 fl oz / 59 ml","finding":"First: Tallow from 100% grass-fed cows; tallow at unknown","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz"}],"references":[{"publisher":"U.S. Food and Drug Administration","title":"Cosmetics Labeling Guide","url":"https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetics-labeling-regulations/cosmetics-labeling-guide","checkedAt":"2026-08-28","role":"Explains ingredient declaration order and the exceptions for ingredients at one percent or less and color additives."}],"human_url":"https://tallowindex.com/notes/tallow-balm-ingredient-order"}