{"schema_version":"living-evidence-note/1","note_id":"note-water-listed","slug":"tallow-balms-that-list-water","question":"Which tallow balms list water as an ingredient?","intended_decision":"Find exact records that list Water without inferring the full formulation type.","answer":"3 of 100 current product records list the exact ingredient name Water.","scope":"This is an exact label-name check. Flower water and leaf juice are not counted as the exact ingredient Water.","method":"Require a supported ingredient-list entry whose released raw name equals Water after case normalization.","metrics":[{"label":"Exact Water matches","value":"3"},{"label":"Records checked","value":"100"},{"label":"Ingredient list unknown","value":"4"}],"limits":["A listed Water entry does not by itself establish the full formulation type or the amount of water.","This exact-name query does not merge Water with rose water, aloe leaf juice, or other water-containing label terms.","An incomplete released list stays unknown."],"release":{"id":"rel-v1.0.0","version":"v1.0.0","status":"published","freshness":{"oldestCheckedAt":"2026-08-27T17:10:00Z","newestCheckedAt":"2026-08-31T17:30:00Z"}},"result_hash":"b874fe9b47456e9bbcf775dfe7509e5676d35afccb105e1429d6042e181daeec","results":[{"product_id":"prod-dr-kellyann-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar","slug":"dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar","brand":"Dr. Kellyann","product_name":"Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"1 Jar","finding":"Water at position 1","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/dr-kellyann-tallow-cream-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-herd-tallow-beef-tallow-moisturizer","variant_id":"var-herd-unscented-2oz","slug":"herd-tallow-moisturizer-unscented-2oz","brand":"Herd Tallow","product_name":"Beef Tallow Moisturizer","exact_variant":"Unscented, 2 oz","finding":"Water at position 3","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/herd-tallow-moisturizer-unscented-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/herd-tallow-moisturizer-unscented-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-age-reverse","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-age-reverse-default","slug":"sun-moo-age-reverse-default","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Age Reverse","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"Water at position 24","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-age-reverse-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-age-reverse-default"}],"references":[],"human_url":"https://tallowindex.com/notes/tallow-balms-that-list-water"}