{"schema_version":"living-evidence-note/1","note_id":"note-short-list-no-essential-oil","slug":"tallow-products-with-short-ingredient-lists-and-no-named-essential-oil","question":"Which tallow products list at most three ingredients and no named essential oil?","intended_decision":"Find short supported lists while excluding records that name an essential oil.","answer":"36 of 112 current product records have at most three listed ingredients and supported evidence that no named essential oil is listed.","scope":"The answer uses supported ingredient lists and the reviewed no-named-essential-oil field for the same variant.","method":"Require one to three supported entries, a supported no-named-essential-oil value, and no contradicting essential-oil wording. Missing evidence does not match.","metrics":[{"label":"Short lists without named essential oil","value":"36"},{"label":"Records checked","value":"112"},{"label":"Ingredient list unknown","value":"4"}],"limits":["No named essential oil is not proof of a complete or essential-oil-free formulation.","This note does not infer safety, quality, performance, or personal fit.","A short list is not treated as better."],"release":{"id":"rel-v1.1.1","version":"v1.1.1","status":"published","freshness":{"oldestCheckedAt":"2026-08-27T17:10:00Z","newestCheckedAt":"2026-09-03T14:17:54.020Z"}},"result_hash":"71e477384dbdd0a1b1adc3e42c514ace5b3b5af75ef6fc371cb0642e717e2726","results":[{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-unscented","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Unscented","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-unscented-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-amallow-whipped-tallow-cream-unscented-jojoba","variant_id":"var-amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar","slug":"amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar","brand":"Amallow","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Cream - Unscented + Jojoba Oil","exact_variant":"1 jar, 4 fl oz","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/amallow-whipped-unscented-jojoba-4floz-1jar"},{"product_id":"prod-austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-austallow-balm","slug":"austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm-50g","brand":"AusTallow","product_name":"Grass-Fed Tallow Balm Moisturizer","exact_variant":"50 g","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm-50g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/austallow-grass-fed-tallow-balm-50g"},{"product_id":"prod-buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm","variant_id":"var-buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default","slug":"buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default","brand":"Buffalo Gal Grassfed Beauty","product_name":"Tallow + Emu Balm","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/buffalo-gal-tallow-emu-balm-2oz-default"},{"product_id":"prod-culver-unscented-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-culver-unscented-4oz","slug":"culver-unscented-whipped-tallow-4oz","brand":"Culver Family Farms","product_name":"Unscented Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"4 fl oz","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/culver-unscented-whipped-tallow-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/culver-unscented-whipped-tallow-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Bare Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"1 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-bare-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Calendula and Rose Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-calendula-rose-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Jojoba Oil and Manuka Honey Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-jojoba-manuka-honey-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Jojoba Oil Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-jojoba-whipped-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml","slug":"ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml","brand":"Ever Tallow","product_name":"Vanilla Bean Whipped Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"50 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ever-tallow-vanilla-bean-tallow-cream-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented","variant_id":"var-fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default","slug":"fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default","brand":"Fierce Nature","product_name":"Nourish Balm (Unscented)","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/fierce-nature-nourish-balm-unscented-default"},{"product_id":"prod-hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm","variant_id":"var-hearth-herb-unscented","slug":"hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm-1-3oz","brand":"Hearth and Homestead","product_name":"Herb-Infused Unscented Whipped Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Small, 1.3 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm-1-3oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/hearth-herb-infused-unscented-balm-1-3oz"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-bare-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-bare-tallow-balm-default","slug":"kai-bare-tallow-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Bare Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-bare-tallow-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-bare-tallow-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-kai-infused-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-kai-infused-tallow-balm-default","slug":"kai-infused-tallow-balm-default","brand":"Kai Tallow","product_name":"Infused Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/kai-infused-tallow-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-infused-tallow-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-nz-tallow-unscented-balm","variant_id":"var-nz-tallow-unscented","slug":"nz-tallow-unscented-balm-70g","brand":"NZ Tallow Co","product_name":"Unscented Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"70 g / 120 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/nz-tallow-unscented-balm-70g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/nz-tallow-unscented-balm-70g"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz","slug":"rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Lavender Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-4oz","slug":"rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-4oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Lavender Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"4 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-09-03","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-lavender-whipped-tallow-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz","slug":"rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Vanilla Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-4oz","slug":"rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-4oz","brand":"Rowe Naturals","product_name":"100% Grass-Fed Vanilla Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"4 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-09-03","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/rowe-vanilla-whipped-tallow-4oz"},{"product_id":"prd-ruth-whipped","variant_id":"var-ruth-whipped-unscented-4oz","slug":"ruth-whipped-tallow-unscented-4oz","brand":"Ruth Family Farms","product_name":"Whipped Beef Tallow","exact_variant":"Unscented, 4 oz","finding":"1 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/ruth-whipped-tallow-unscented-4oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/ruth-whipped-tallow-unscented-4oz"},{"product_id":"prod-sun-moo-the-simple-one","variant_id":"var-sun-moo-simple-one-2oz","slug":"sun-moo-simple-one-2oz","brand":"Sun & Moo","product_name":"The Simple One","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/sun-moo-simple-one-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/sun-moo-simple-one-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tall-owl-whipped-tallow","variant_id":"var-tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz","slug":"tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz","brand":"Tall Owl","product_name":"Whipped Tallow","exact_variant":"Unscented / 3.0 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tall-owl-whipped-tallow-unscented-3oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream","variant_id":"var-tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml","slug":"tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml","brand":"Tallo Skin","product_name":"Skin Tallow Cream","exact_variant":"100 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallo-skin-skin-tallow-cream-100ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-tallow-balm-shop-original-100g","slug":"tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm-100g","brand":"Tallow Balm Shop","product_name":"Original Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"100 g","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm-100g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tallow-balm-shop-original-tallow-balm-100g"},{"product_id":"prod-tarro-calm-balm","variant_id":"var-tarro-calm-balm-30g","slug":"tarro-calm-balm-30g","brand":"Tarro","product_name":"Calm Balm","exact_variant":"30 g","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tarro-calm-balm-30g","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tarro-calm-balm-30g"},{"product_id":"prod-the-cow-balm-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-cow-balm-unscented","slug":"the-cow-balm-unscented-50ml","brand":"The Cow Balm","product_name":"Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"Unscented, 50 ml","finding":"1 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/the-cow-balm-unscented-50ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/the-cow-balm-unscented-50ml"},{"product_id":"prod-toups-hydrating-tallow-stick","variant_id":"var-toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-default","slug":"toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-standard","brand":"Toups and Co Organics","product_name":"Hydrating Tallow Stick","exact_variant":"Standard","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-standard","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/toups-hydrating-tallow-stick-standard"},{"product_id":"prod-toups-tallow-balm-unscented","variant_id":"var-toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","slug":"toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","brand":"Toups and Co Organics","product_name":"Tallow Balm Unscented","exact_variant":"2 oz","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/toups-tallow-balm-unscented-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm","variant_id":"var-tricity-pure-200ml","slug":"tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-200ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Pure Tallow Skin Balm","exact_variant":"200 ml","finding":"1 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-200ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-200ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-trial","variant_id":"var-tricity-pure-60ml","slug":"tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-60ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Pure Tallow Skin Balm Trial","exact_variant":"60 ml","finding":"1 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-60ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-pure-tallow-skin-balm-60ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm","variant_id":"var-tricity-honey-200ml","slug":"tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm-200ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Tallow and Honey Skin Balm","exact_variant":"200 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm-200ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-tallow-honey-skin-balm-200ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter","variant_id":"var-tricity-whipped-200ml","slug":"tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter-200ml","brand":"Tri-City","product_name":"Whipped Tallow Body Butter","exact_variant":"200 ml","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"verified","checked_at":"2026-08-27","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter-200ml","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tri-city-whipped-tallow-body-butter-200ml"},{"product_id":"prod-tropical-tallow-body-balm","variant_id":"var-tropical-tallow-body-balm-default","slug":"tropical-tallow-body-balm-default","brand":"Tropical Tallow","product_name":"Body Balm","exact_variant":"Default","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-28","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/tropical-tallow-body-balm-default","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/tropical-tallow-body-balm-default"},{"product_id":"prod-vanman-no-essential-oils-tallow-honey-face-balm-classic","variant_id":"var-vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz","slug":"vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz","brand":"VanMan","product_name":"No Essential Oils Tallow & Honey Face Balm - Classic","exact_variant":"Jumbo 6 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-6oz"},{"product_id":"prod-vanman-no-essential-oils-tallow-honey-face-balm-classic","variant_id":"var-vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz","slug":"vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz","brand":"VanMan","product_name":"No Essential Oils Tallow & Honey Face Balm - Classic","exact_variant":"Original 2 oz","finding":"3 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vanman-no-essential-oils-classic-2oz"},{"product_id":"prod-vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-tallow-balm","variant_id":"var-vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz","slug":"vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz","brand":"Vintage Tradition","product_name":"Totally Unscented Tallow Balm","exact_variant":"2 fl oz / 59 ml","finding":"2 listed ingredients; no named essential-oil entry","evidence_state":"single_source","checked_at":"2026-08-29","product_url":"https://tallowindex.com/products/vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/vintage-tradition-totally-unscented-2floz"}],"references":[],"human_url":"https://tallowindex.com/notes/tallow-products-with-short-ingredient-lists-and-no-named-essential-oil"}