{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29T20:00:00Z","data":{"assertions":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"verified","fieldKey":"fragrance_free","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-fragrance_free","label":"Fragrance-free evidence","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official page identifies a Blue Tansy Frost scent.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":false},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"single_source","fieldKey":"ingredient_list","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-ingredient_list","label":"Listed ingredients","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official Full Ingredient Quality Breakdown: Beef Tallow; Jojoba Oil Infused with Wild Bald Cypress & Chamomile; Blue Tansy Flower Oil; Vitamin E (Tocopherol).","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":["Beef Tallow","Jojoba Oil Infused with Wild Bald Cypress & Chamomile","Blue Tansy Flower Oil","Vitamin E (Tocopherol)"]},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"verified","fieldKey":"listed_price","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-listed_price","label":"Listed price","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Selected Shopify variant and official page: USD 44.00 one-time price.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":"USD","value":44},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"unknown","fieldKey":"size","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-size","label":"Listed size","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"The official page does not state a supported fill size for the default variant. Shopify shipping weight is not used as fill size.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":null},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"verified","fieldKey":"grass_fed_claim","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-grass_fed_claim","label":"Manufacturer grass-fed claim","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official product ingredient details identify the beef tallow as 100% grass-fed and grass-finished.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":true},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"verified","fieldKey":"availability","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-availability","label":"Merchant availability","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Selected Shopify variant data: available false; official page says Sold out.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":"out_of_stock"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"verified","fieldKey":"scent","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-scent","label":"Named scent","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official product page and embedded Shopify data: Winter Balm; product ID 10461571219761; variant ID 52077738721585; SKU KT-WB-029.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":"Blue Tansy Frost"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","conflictState":"none","evidenceState":"verified","fieldKey":"essential_oil_free","id":"v100-v0140-v0130-v0120-v0110-v0100-ast-v090-kai-winter-balm-default-essential_oil_free","label":"No named essential oil listed","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"The declaration includes Blue Tansy Flower Oil and the page identifies a strong botanical scent. No essential-oil-free claim is used.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"unit":null,"value":false}],"ingredients":[{"displayName":"Beef tallow","ingredientSlug":"beef-tallow","mappingState":"confirmed","position":1,"rawName":"Beef Tallow","topicName":"Beef tallow","topicSlug":"beef-tallow"},{"displayName":"Jojoba Oil Infused with Wild Bald Cypress & Chamomile","ingredientSlug":"jojoba-oil-infused-with-wild-bald-cypress-chamomile","mappingState":null,"position":2,"rawName":"Jojoba Oil Infused with Wild Bald Cypress & Chamomile","topicName":null,"topicSlug":null},{"displayName":"Blue Tansy Flower Oil","ingredientSlug":"blue-tansy-flower-oil","mappingState":null,"position":3,"rawName":"Blue Tansy Flower Oil","topicName":null,"topicSlug":null},{"displayName":"Vitamin E (Tocopherol)","ingredientSlug":"vitamin-e-tocopherol","mappingState":"confirmed","position":4,"rawName":"Vitamin E (Tocopherol)","topicName":"Vitamin E / Tocopherol","topicSlug":"vitamin-e"}],"product":{"availability":"out_of_stock","brand":"Kai Tallow","brand_slug":"kai-tallow","checked_at":"2026-08-29T20:00:00Z","essential_oil_free":false,"essential_oil_free_scope":"Legacy field name. The value records whether the released evidence names an essential oil, or states that none are named. It does not prove the complete formulation.","evidence_receipt_url":"https://tallowindex.com/api/v1/releases/rel-v1.0.0/evidence/kai-winter-balm-default","evidence_state":"unknown","evidence_state_scope":"Least certain released assertion for this exact variant. Use field_evidence for the state of each match fact.","evidence_url":"https://tallowindex.com/evidence/kai-winter-balm-default","exact_variant":"Default","field_evidence":{"fragrance_free":{"evidence_state":"verified"},"grass_fed_claim":{"evidence_state":"verified"},"no_named_essential_oil_listed":{"evidence_state":"verified","scope":"Released evidence names no essential oil. This does not prove the complete formulation or safety."}},"fragrance_free":false,"grass_fed_claim":true,"ingredient_count":4,"latest_price":{"amount_minor":4400,"currency":"USD"},"merchant_listing":{"merchant":"Kai Tallow","relationship":"none","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},"no_named_essential_oil_listed":false,"product_id":"prod-kai-winter-balm","product_name":"Winter Balm","product_slug":"kai-winter-balm","release":{"id":"rel-v1.0.0","status":"published","version":"v1.0.0"},"scent":"Blue Tansy Frost","schema_version":"1.0.0","size":null,"slug":"kai-winter-balm-default","variant_id":"var-kai-winter-balm-default"}},"evidenceState":"unknown","issuedAt":"2026-08-31T17:30:00Z","previousReceiptHash":null,"receiptHash":"bea8976838395ddb3ac0e838ed04fd4ae92943c63f5f8d94dc98e7c494407936","receiptId":"rel-v1.0.0:var-kai-winter-balm-default","releaseId":"rel-v1.0.0","releaseManifestHash":"169792062d180cae209af9278771cd44ac01f046f99cb4eaffc900c5dad91612","releaseStatus":"published","releaseVersion":"v1.0.0","schema":"tallow-evidence-receipt/1","sources":[{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official page identifies a Blue Tansy Frost scent.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official Full Ingredient Quality Breakdown: Beef Tallow; Jojoba Oil Infused with Wild Bald Cypress & Chamomile; Blue Tansy Flower Oil; Vitamin E (Tocopherol).","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Selected Shopify variant and official page: USD 44.00 one-time price.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"The official page does not state a supported fill size for the default variant. Shopify shipping weight is not used as fill size.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official product ingredient details identify the beef tallow as 100% grass-fed and grass-finished.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Selected Shopify variant data: available false; official page says Sold out.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"Official product page and embedded Shopify data: Winter Balm; product ID 10461571219761; variant ID 52077738721585; SKU KT-WB-029.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"},{"checkedAt":"2026-08-29","evidenceLocator":"The declaration includes Blue Tansy Flower Oil and the page identifies a strong botanical scent. No essential-oil-free claim is used.","id":"src-kai-winter-balm-default","publisher":"Kai Tallow","snapshotHash":"be2dc77190ed9a10191c706b63e905b38317ccd561a2672d84e0abbdd7406224","sourceTier":1,"sourceType":"manufacturer","url":"https://www.kaitallow.com/products/seasonal-winter-balm?variant=52077738721585"}],"subject":"kai-winter-balm-default"}